Have you ever noticed how the biggest and most dramatic breakups in bands tend to involve a female vocalist leaving? I’m here to call out some inherent misogyny in the heavy metal scene that relates to the way fans react when women leave their bands, as opposed to men. Think about it. How many big, dramatic shit-shows have there been in the last year alone due to female vocalists leaving their bands? I can name at least four: Alissa White-Gluz dropped out of Arch Enemy, Noora Louhimo parted ways with Battle Beast, Diana Leah said farewell to Delain, and, of course, the biggest fan shit-fest of them all, Floor Jansen leaving Nightwish.
So, I’m going to explore how inherent sexism affects musical fanbases—specifically in heavy metal, though this is surely valid across the board—and why women aren’t allowed to leave metal bands, while men are, though I will delve into some exceptions to the rule and why they happen.
Men are not allowed to leave when their identity is too strong, otherwise it’s fine…
(Political Disclaimer: to be clear, I do not currently condone Iced Earth due to the band’s MAGA status, but they make for an interesting case study)
To anyone who’s already screaming at me that I’m wrong, the examples you’re probably thinking of are Bruce Dickinson and Rob Halford when they left Iron Maiden and Judas Priest respectively, and perhaps Matt Barlow’s departure from Iced Earth. Fan reactions to these changes were indeed pretty strong, but what do they all have in common? The singers were replaced by someone who couldn’t do what the original did, not even close. While Blaze Bayley is a perfectly decent singer in his own right, he was a lukewarm replacement for the Air Raid Siren at best, and funnily enough, Tim “Ripper” Owens was the replacement for both Halford and Barlow (the first time, at least). Owens simply couldn’t sing the way Halford or Barlow could, but you might note that when Barlow was replaced a second time by Stu Block—a singer who had a significantly more similar sound to Barlow—there wasn’t nearly the same stink.
An interesting contrast to this was when Roy Khan left Kamelot. I certainly remember there being a strong fan panic when this happened, but when they replaced him with Tommy Karevik, fans were pretty well-sated when they realized that he sounds very similar, and perhaps noted that he’s a better live performer to boot.
Another one is Black Sabbath. There was never much backlash when they went through Ozzy Osbourne, Ronnie James Dio, Ian Gillan, and others. Perhaps because each of them was unique and talented in their own way, but there weren’t any big fat nasty explosions from the fanbases when any of these fellows wanted to pursue their own projects.
So here’s my point: when male singers leave for reasons like Roy Khan’s spiritual crisis, burnout, and insomnia, or the second time when Matt Barlow left due to his commitments to his family and his police work, when they were appropriately replaced, neither band needed to launch a massive PR campaign to save face. Fans accepted these changes on the chin, with minimal grumbling.
The exception that proves the rule…
Now, to hone in on this point, let’s look back at Nightwish, because some of you might be thinking about what happened when Marko Hietala left. He, like Dickinson, Halford, and Barlow, has a deeply unique and powerful voice that’s nigh impossible to replicate—and was ultimately never replaced as a vocalist because of it—and the Nightwish fanbase definitely had their struggles with his departure. While some fans inevitably blamed Tuomas Holopainen for him leaving (despite Hietala distinctly asking them not to), Hietala called out shady streaming services, corrupt labels, and greedy management as the reason for his departure, along with his complicated mental health, and fans celebrated and supported him. Almost no one accused him of being a diva or betraying his fanbase. The band had to scramble before the tour because of this, but he didn’t face the same sort of character assassinations that Tarja Turunen or Anette Olzon or Floor Jansen have faced.
Ergo, do you think maybe fans have a bit too strong of an attachment to their female vocalists?
Women must be married to their bands and when they leave it’s an ugly divorce…
Let’s start this out by looking at the biggest fan soap opera in symphonic metal, Nightwish:
When Tarja Turunen was fired from Nightwish, it was a massive catastrophe, perhaps due in large part to the public nature of the split, which they seem to have since learned was perhaps not the best way to deal with personal matters. There were character assassinations aplenty on both sides, and even though they’ve all made up at this point, the fans still vehemently hold grudges about this breakup that occurred over 20 years ago. Fans went so far as to theorize that there was a toxic love triangle between Holopainen, Turunen, and Turunen’s husband, of which there is absolutely no proof whatsoever.
When Anette Olzon departed abruptly mid-tour, even though they kept things more private this time around, the fans once again started picking sides, blaming her for being a demanding diva, or once again blaming Tuomas for being a monster that can’t work with women, heaping the character assassinations on both sides.
And now that Floor Jansen has left, there’s yet another great divide. The Tuomas haters are back out in full force, while Floor’s been, once again, called a bitch diva who has abandoned her fanbase for selfish reasons, as if having different wants for the future than Nightwish can provide make her a monster. Meanwhile, Tuomas is facing constant fan allegations that he’s a terrible human being who abuses women and creates a hostile working environment. As I’ve mentioned in other articles, there are a lot of men out there who have very strong artistic visions that don’t take a lot of external feedback (Arjen Lucassen, Chrigel Glanzmann, Martijn Westerholt, and Tuomas Holopainen have all openly admitted that they’re perfectionists and can be tough to work with), but that doesn’t mean that they’re toxic lunatics. Being difficult doesn’t automatically equate to being a crazy screaming maniac the way some fans seem to think it does.
Explore that a bit: Arjen Lucassen’s simply created his band around the cycling in of vocalists, so he doesn’t get shit when he doesn’t invite someone back. Chrigel Glanzmann has been through multiple lineup changes and Eluveitie is still as popular as ever. But with Nightwish and Delain, there’s always this rage getting elicited from fans that always frames things as a toxic split of man versus woman.
So why is it that the fanbases always treat these splits as bitter, hateful divorces? Okay, I admit that Jansen fully called the mutually-agreed split from Nightwish like a break-up, but once again, not all break-ups are bitter and spiteful. Break-ups, as a rule, are pretty much always for the best, if not financially, at least emotionally. If Floor and the rest of Nightwish weren’t able to get on the same page regarding their wants and needs, that’s fine. Nobody needs to be demonized for making a sensible life choice.
To quote one gross man who is nevertheless onto something:
Some more examples of how women aren’t allowed to follow their own paths without extreme fan drama…
First up, let’s look at Delain. Despite the whole band leaving Westerholt, Charlotte Wessels was the particular sticking point for everything. Fans treated this as an apocalyptic betrayal and the degree of vitriol getting spewed was staggering. Realistically, there were a lot of different needs going around that couldn’t be resolved after a year of effort, so it simply made sense that they all had to part ways, but the fan reaction to this was horrifying, demonizing one side or the other. While the backlash isn’t as strong now that Diana Leah has chosen to focus more on her solo career, there’s still a lot of hate flowing towards Westerholt because a woman has chosen to pursue her own path. Why is that, do you think, that everyone views these splits as if the singer and writer are in a personal relationship? And why is it that, even when the band can handle it with maturity, the fans cannot? It seems like the female vocalists are treated by fans as the emotional anchor to the band and if she leaves or is fired, it’s the end of life as we know it.
There’s also been another Great Divide between Battle Beast and Noora Louhimo. Remember back in the day, when the band booted their founder, Anton Kabanen? That was a pretty fiery, angry break-up from the band and its maker, yet the backlash from it was essentially nothing. Kabanen went on to form the extremely popular Beast in Black and Battle Beast went on to continue being equally popular. Now that Noora has left the band, however, everyone seems to be picking sides. Who takes the brunt of it? The women. Noora’s being heavily criticized for leaving metal (even though she’s promised that it’s just one of many musical loves for her, which is proven by her 100%-non-metal Noora Louhimo Experience solo album that she released while still actively in Battle Beast), while Battle Beast are struggling with their new singer, Marina La Toracca, because Louhimo’s fans refuse to give her a chance, even though Noora was never one of the songwriters (credited in only four songs, I think)—part of the reason she chose to leave. [ed: by the women taking the brunt of it, I mean re: comments; Battle Beast are struggling more as a whole post-break, but it is the women who are under the critical lens]
Now, I didn’t follow the split with Alissa White-Gluz and Arch Enemy because I don’t listen to them, but there is something worthwhile to point out there. Back in the day, when Angela Gossow left Arch Enemy, she was allowed to do so because she stayed on as the band manager. When White-Gluz left because of burnout, industry disgust, and a desire to pursue other projects, she was immediately rumored to be difficult to work with. Those are two of the three exact reasons that Marko Hietala left Nightwish, yet he was treated with sympathy and support, while White-Gluz was immediately demonized.
Anyone seeing the pattern yet?
Here’s my theory…
When it comes to women in music, fans who react this way haven’t actually formed a deep relationship with the music. Or if they have, that’s not what they’re reacting to when headlines hit. What they’ve actually done is form an unhealthy one-sided parasocial relationship with the female vocalist due to internalized misogyny and feelings of ownership towards women. Yes, this happens to fans who are men and women and non-binaries alike. The reaction isn’t the same as you get from fans of all-male groups, where they are treated with respect for artistic vision, mental health, and business decisions. Rather, fans act as though they have personally been dumped and begin crafting all sorts of fantasies to justify their own feelings.
It might be worthwhile for fans to remember that the important thing is the music. Artists are not fictional characters. They are not emotional support animals. They are not in a personal relationship with the fans. Men are allowed to burn out, break down, and make business and artistic decisions without much in the way of repercussions, while any choice that women make, or bands make with regard to the women, is taken personally. Perhaps it’s time to tone down the parasocial entitlement, stop treating career choices as personal betrayals, and let women move on with the same respect that men get by default. Can you imagine, if every time you decided you didn’t want to work at a job anymore, everyone treated you like a hot-headed diva bitch and spent all their time on the internet talking about what that means about you as a person, while having never actually met you? No? Then consider doing unto others as you would have done unto you.
Cheers, and stay balanced, folks!